A framework for developing and identifying learning resources
Claims, comparisons, choices
What knowledge and skills do people need in order to be able to assess the trustworthiness of claims about treatments and make informed health choices? We have developed a list of 44 Key Concepts that make up a framework of what people need to understand and be able to apply. The concepts are organised in three groups, to help people:
1. Recognise when a claim about the effects of treatments has an untrustworthy basis
2. Recognise when evidence from comparisons of treatments is trustworthy and when it is not
3. Make well-informed choices about treatments
This grouping does not reflect the difficulty of the concepts or the order in which they should be learned.
Using these universally relevant concepts as a starting point, we develop targeted learning resources to teach people in different settings to understand and apply them. But the list of Key Concepts itself is not meant to be a learning resource (so some parts may be unfamiliar and difficult to understand). Rather, the list provides a framework or starting point for teachers, journalists and other intermediaries who are identifying learning resources (such as longer explanations, examples, games and interactive applications) or, like ourselves, developing new learning resources.
Developing the Key Concepts
The first version of the Key Concepts list was published in 2015 and has been updated yearly since then:
- Key Concept description and development
- 2015 version
- 2016 version
- 2017 version
- 2018 version (current)
Relevant across many fields
Although we have developed and framed the Key Concepts to address health treatment claims, people in other fields have also found them relevant. Work to adapt these concepts to apply to interventions in other fields is ongoing, including educational, environmental, agricultural, economic, international development, management, nutrition, policing, social welfare, and veterinary interventions.
Blogs and other resources
Students 4 Best Evidence believe these Key Concepts are vital to help them think critically about the treatment claims they’re exposed to daily and were keen to raise awareness of them. As such, a group of over 10 students has prepared a series of 34 blogs, one to explain and elaborate upon each of the Key Concepts in the 2016 version. Other teams are translating the blog series to Portuguese, German, Spanish, Croatian and Dutch. We will link to these translations when they are completed.
Other learning resources for teaching the IHC Key Concepts can be found in the Critical thinking and Appraisal Resource Library (CARL).